CoolFace
Datasetpublic

liveplex/robogate-failure-dictionary

RoboGate Failure Dictionary 50,000+ Physics-Validated Pick & Place Failure Patterns across 4 Robots (Franka Panda, UR5e, UR3e, UR10e) A structured database of robot AI failure patterns collected from NVIDIA Isaac Sim physical simulations using Two-Stage Adaptive Sampling. Each experiment records the exact conditions under which a robot succeeded or failed at Pick & Place tasks. Quick Stats Franka Uniform Franka Boundary UR5e UR3e UR10e Combined… See the full description on the dataset page: https://huggingface.co/datasets/liveplex/robogate-failure-dictionary.

sourceHugging Facemitupdated 1mo agoView on Hugging Face
0likes166downloads
Dataset Card

RoboGate Failure Dictionary

50,000+ Physics-Validated Pick & Place Failure Patterns across 4 Robots (Franka Panda, UR5e, UR3e, UR10e)

A structured database of robot AI failure patterns collected from NVIDIA Isaac Sim physical simulations using Two-Stage Adaptive Sampling. Each experiment records the exact conditions under which a robot succeeded or failed at Pick & Place tasks.

Quick Stats

Franka UniformFranka BoundaryUR5eUR3eUR10eCombined
Experiments10,00010,00010,00010,00010,00050,000+
Success Rate33.3%63.8%74.3%10.0%0.0%
Franka Combined48.6%
Risk Model AUC0.650.7770.777
SamplingUniform LHSBoundary LHSUniform LHSUniform LHSUniform LHSTwo-Stage

Key Findings

  • friction × mass interaction z = -10.00 — strongest predictor of failure
  • Friction threshold: 0.492 ± 0.031 — below this, failure cascades
  • Mass > 0.93 kg → Both robots fail at < 40% SR (universal danger zone)
  • Boundary equation: μ*(m) = (1.469 + 0.419m) / (3.691 - 1.400m)
  • AUC improved 0.65 → 0.777 (+19.5%) with boundary-focused sampling
  • Failure mode transition: friction↓ → timeout → collision → grasp_miss

Two-Stage Adaptive Sampling

Stage 1 — Uniform Exploration (40,000)

  • Franka Panda 10K + UR5e 10K
  • Latin Hypercube Sampling for uniform parameter space coverage
  • Identified boundary regions and initial risk model (AUC 0.65)

Stage 2 — Boundary-Focused (10,000)

  • Franka Panda only, targeting boundary/transition regions
  • Concentrated sampling near friction threshold 0.492
  • Revealed failure mode transitions invisible to uniform sampling
  • Boosted Risk Model AUC to 0.777 (+19.5%)

Universal Danger Zones (mass > 0.93 kg)

Mass RangeFranka SRUR5e SR
0.93 – 1.23 kg21.4%30.9%
1.23 – 1.52 kg14.9%25.3%
1.52 – 1.82 kg12.5%28.9%
1.82 – 2.11 kg6.6%28.1%

Usage

python
from datasets import load_dataset

ds = load_dataset("liveplex/robogate-failure-dictionary")
print(ds["train"][0])

# Filter danger zones
danger = ds["train"].filter(lambda x: x["zone"] == "danger")
print(f"Danger zones: {len(danger)}")

Parameter Space

ParameterRangeScalePaper
friction0.05 – 1.2log-uniformSIMPLER 2024
mass0.05 – 2.0 kglog-uniformSIMPLER 2024
com_offset0.0 – 0.40uniformSuction Grasp 2025
size0.02 – 0.12 muniformSIMPLER 2024
ik_noise0.0 – 0.04 raduniformICRA Sim2Real 2025
obstacles0 – 4integerRoboFAC 2025
shape5 typescategoricalGrasp Anything 2024
placement14 typescategoricalALEAS 2025

Research Foundations

Design ChoicePaperYear
Two-Stage Adaptive SamplingALEAS2025
friction × mass interactionSIMPLERCoRL 2024
Failure taxonomyRoboFACNeurIPS 2025
Cross-robot validationRoboMINDRSS 2025
UR-specific failuresGuardianICRA 2025
Confidence intervalsSureSimBadithela 2025
GPU simulationIsaac LabNVIDIA 2025
Grasp evaluationIsaac Sim Grasping SDGNVIDIA 2025

VLA Benchmark — 4-Model Leaderboard

Four VLA models evaluated on RoboGate's 68-scenario adversarial suite. All scored 0% SR — including NVIDIA's official GR00T N1.6.

ModelParamsSRConfidenceFailure Pattern
Scripted Controller100% (68/68)76/100
GR00T N1.6 (NVIDIA)3B0% (0/68)1/100grasp_miss + collision
OpenVLA (Stanford + TRI)7B0% (0/68)27/100grasp_miss dominant, 0 collision
Octo-Base (UC Berkeley)93M0% (0/68)1/100grasp_miss 79%, collision 21%
Octo-Small (UC Berkeley)27M0% (0/68)1/100grasp_miss 79.4%, collision 20.6%

Model size is not the bottleneck — even NVIDIA's flagship 3B model cannot bridge the training-deployment distribution gap.

Leaderboard: robogate.io/vla · Paper: arXiv:2603.22126

Citation

bibtex
@dataset{robogate_failure_dictionary_2026,
  title={RoboGate Failure Dictionary: 50K+ Physics-Validated Pick & Place Failure Patterns},
  author={RoboGate Team},
  year={2026},
  url={https://huggingface.co/datasets/liveplex/robogate-failure-dictionary},
  note={Franka Panda + UR3e + UR5e + UR10e, Two-Stage Adaptive Sampling, AUC 0.777}
}

Links