CoolFace
Datasetpublic

x65617379/lesswrong_260509

codex dataset card > generated by Codex_ Dataset Card for lesswrong_260509 Dataset Summary A structured crawl of public longform posts and comments from LessWrong, a ForumMagnum-powered discussion site focused on rationality, cognitive science, AI alignment, forecasting, philosophy, and related topics. The dataset contains 45,933 posts and 906,338 comments, preserving one flat comment list per post with parent IDs, nesting depth, orphan markers, timestamps… See the full description on the dataset page: https://huggingface.co/datasets/x65617379/lesswrong_260509.

sourceHugging Faceunknownupdated 5mo agoView on Hugging Face
2likes104downloads
Dataset Card

<div style=" display: inline-block; width: fit-content; max-width: 100%; background: #0b0f14; border: 1px solid #223044; border-left: 5px solid #20c997; border-radius: 8px; padding: 14px 18px; margin-bottom: 20px; color: #e6edf3; font-family: ui-monospace, SFMono-Regular, Menlo, Monaco, Consolas, 'Liberation Mono', monospace; box-shadow: 0 8px 24px rgba(15, 23, 42, 0.18); "> <p style=" margin: 0 0 6px 0; color: #8aa2bd; font-size: 12px; line-height: 1.4; text-transform: uppercase; ">codex dataset card</p> <p style=" margin: 0; color: #e6edf3; font-size: 15px; font-weight: 650; line-height: 1.45; "><span style="color:#20c997;">&gt;</span> generated by <span style="color:#ffffff;">Codex</span><span style="color:#20c997;">_</span></p> </div>

Dataset Card for lesswrong_260509

Dataset Summary

A structured crawl of public longform posts and comments from LessWrong, a ForumMagnum-powered discussion site focused on rationality, cognitive science, AI alignment, forecasting, philosophy, and related topics. The dataset contains 45,933 posts and 906,338 comments, preserving one flat comment list per post with parent IDs, nesting depth, orphan markers, timestamps, scores, vote counts, author metadata, and post-level flags.

The crawl targets public, approved, non-draft, non-future, listed, non-shortform posts visible to an anonymous LessWrong GraphQL requester.


Dataset Details

Dataset Description

  • Language(s): English
  • Crawl date: 2026-05-06 to 2026-05-09

Dataset Sources

  • Source Website: https://www.lesswrong.com
  • Source API: https://www.lesswrong.com/graphql

Uses

Direct Use

Suitable for:

  • Academic research into forum dynamics and longform online discussion
  • Computational social science research on rationalist and AI safety communities
  • Linguistic analysis of argumentative, technical, and speculative web discourse
  • Studying thread/reply structures, voting patterns, and moderation markers
  • Information retrieval and semantic search over LessWrong posts and discussions

Dataset Structure

Schema

ColumnTypeDescription
sourcestructCrawl/source metadata for the row
poststructPost metadata and body content
comments_flat_countint64Number of comments in the comments list
commentslist<struct>Flat list of comments associated with the post
Source Struct
FieldTypeDescription
lesswrong_graphqlstringLessWrong GraphQL endpoint used for the crawl
lesswrong_urlstringDirect LessWrong URL for the post
greaterwrong_urlstringCorresponding GreaterWrong mirror URL
fetched_atstringISO-8601 timestamp when the record was fetched
Post Struct
FieldTypeDescription
_idstringUnique post identifier
titlestringPost title
slugstringURL slug
pageUrlstringFull LessWrong URL
pageUrlRelativestringRelative LessWrong URL path
urlstring or nullExternal URL for link posts
postedAtstringPost timestamp (ISO-8601)
baseScoreint64Net score at crawl time
voteCountint64Vote count at crawl time
wordCountint64Word count reported by LessWrong
htmlBodystringPost body in HTML
metaboolWhether the post is marked as meta
questionboolWhether the post is marked as a question
isEventboolWhether the post is an event post
frontpageDatestring or nullFrontpage timestamp, if present
curatedDatestring or nullCurated timestamp, if present
legacyIdstring or nullLegacy LessWrong identifier, if present
userstructAuthor info (_id, username, slug, displayName)
Comment Struct
FieldTypeDescription
_idstringUnique comment identifier
postIdstringParent post ID
parentCommentIdstring or nullID of the parent comment this replies to
topLevelCommentIdstring or nullID of the top-level ancestor comment
pageUrlstringDirect LessWrong URL for the comment
pageUrlRelativestringRelative LessWrong URL path
postedAtstringComment timestamp (ISO-8601)
baseScoreint64Net score at crawl time
voteCountint64Vote count at crawl time
wordCountint64Word count reported by LessWrong
htmlBodystringComment body in HTML
deletedboolWhether the comment is deleted
deletedPublicboolWhether the deletion is public
retractedboolWhether the comment is retracted
legacyIdstring or nullLegacy LessWrong identifier, if present
userstructAuthor info (_id, username, slug, displayName)
positionint641-based position in pre-order traversal within the post's comment list
depthint64Nesting depth (0 = top-level comment or orphan-root comment)
orphanboolWhether the comment was associated with the post but not attached to the main comment tree

Statistics

MetricValue
Posts45,933
Non-orphan comments902,220
Orphan comments4,118
Total comments906,338
Post date range2005-01-01 to 2026-05-06
Comment date range2006-11-22 to 2026-05-09
Crawl timestamp range2026-05-06 to 2026-05-09
Mean comments per post19.7
Median comments per post4
Longest post thread2,001 comments
Max nesting depth91
Post authors6,581
Comment authors22,139
Posts with no author1,510 (3.3%)
Link posts5,516 (12.0%)
Text posts40,417 (88.0%)
Posts with no comments12,059 (26.3%)
Meta posts213 (0.5%)
Question posts2,689 (5.9%)
Event posts2,095 (4.6%)
Frontpage posts22,581 (49.2%)
Curated posts738 (1.6%)
Negative-score posts1,904 (4.1%)
Mean post word count1,324
Median post word count577
Mean post body HTML length19,154 characters
Median post body HTML length4,742 characters
Mean comment word count106
Median comment word count60
Blank comment bodies2,336 (0.3%)
Deleted comments1,838 (0.2%)
Retracted comments10,239 (1.1%)

The most prolific post authors include Eliezer Yudkowsky (1,048 posts), Zvi (989), jefftk (921), Stuart_Armstrong (811), and KatjaGrace (632). The most prolific comment authors include ChristianKl (13,987 comments), wedrifid (13,141), Lumifer (11,480), gwern (10,952), and Vladimir_Nesov (8,612).


Dataset Creation

Curation Rationale

LessWrong is a long-running forum for rationality, AI alignment, decision theory, philosophy, cognitive science, and adjacent technical discussion. A structured archive makes this corpus available for research into longform online discourse, intellectual community dynamics, and the development of AI safety and rationalist discussion over time.

Source Data

Data Collection and Processing
  • Tool: Custom Python script using the public LessWrong GraphQL API
  • Scope: Public, approved, non-draft, non-future, listed, non-shortform posts visible to anonymous GraphQL requests
  • No filtering was applied to fetched content; all crawled posts and comments are included
  • Comments are stored as a single flat list in the comments column
  • Parent-child relationships are preserved using parentCommentId, topLevelCommentId, position, and depth
  • Comments that could not be attached to the main comment tree are retained in comments with orphan = true
  • Score and vote counts are snapshot values from crawl time
Who are the source data producers?

LessWrong users posting under real names or pseudonymous usernames.


Bias, Risks, and Limitations

Content Risks

  • Content reflects the interests, norms, and epistemic commitments of the LessWrong community
  • Posts may contain speculative, controversial, or technical claims presented with varying levels of evidence
  • Discussions may include sensitive topics such as AI existential risk, mental health, bioethics, politics, religion, self-experimentation, and personal life decisions
  • Historical posts may contain outdated claims, broken links, or references to community controversies

Structural Limitations

  • The crawl was conducted from 2026-05-06 to 2026-05-09 and includes no content discovered beyond that snapshot
  • The latest post in the shards is dated 2026-05-06, while the latest comment is dated 2026-05-09
  • Vote counts, scores, curation status, frontpage status, deletion markers, and retraction markers are snapshot values and may have changed since crawl time
  • The dataset is limited to content discoverable through the public GraphQL API without privileged access
  • Some older imported LessWrong content has missing author metadata or legacy formatting artifacts in htmlBody
  • A small number of comments are marked with orphan = true because they could not be attached to the main comment tree

Personal and Sensitive Information

  • No systematic PII detection or redaction was performed
  • Many users post under stable pseudonyms, and some post under real names
  • Posts and comments may contain references to real individuals, organizations, events, or personal experiences
  • The dataset should be treated as containing potentially sensitive information

Licence and Redistribution

No licence was identified for the source forum content. This dataset is therefore marked as license: unknown.

The dataset consists of scraped public forum posts authored by third parties. The dataset publisher does not claim ownership of the underlying post text and does not grant additional rights beyond any rights users may already have under applicable law.

Users are responsible for determining whether their intended use is lawful, including with respect to copyright, privacy, data protection, and platform terms.